Best Pizza in Oneonta

A Legendary Pizza Spot Serving Oneonta since 1977

NOW OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK!

Hours: Monday through Thursday: 11am to 9pm. Friday and Saturday: 11am to 10pm. Sunday: 12pm to 8pm.

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Traditional Pie (Small 14'')

Classic cheese or create your own pizza by choosing your favorite toppings

Add Item

Traditional Pie (Large 18'')

Classic cheese or create your own pizza by choosing your favorite toppings

Add Item

Sheet Pizza

24 cut

Add Item

Pizza Made With Passion

Pizza Made With Passion
For generations, pizza has been our way to bring joy and fun to everyone who walks through our door. Our skilled pizza makers use fresh ingredients to make each pizza special, from cheesy classics to exciting new pies. To us, pizza-making is an art, created with care and passion. Whether you're here for a quick bite or a big meal with family, when you want a meal that hits the spot, Sal's New Classic Pizzeria is the place to go!
Order Now

A Popular Place for All Kinds of Crowds

A Popular Place for All Kinds of Crowds
Sal's is for everyone. We welcome all - the loud laughers, the silent diners, and everyone in between. Whether you're a kid after a soccer game, a family celebrating a birthday, or just someone looking for a chill place to eat, we've got you covered. Our pizzas are just as diverse - we've got everything from classic Margherita to unique creations like our Rodeo pie. No matter what you choose, a pie from Sal's is perfect for sharing, making memories, and having a great time.
Order Online

Kitchen Bites, Salads, Desserts, and More!

Kitchen Bites, Salads, Desserts, and More!
Our menu's packed with goodies beyond our pizzas! Try our Honey BBQ Wings – or our garlic knots - two of our most popular menu items. Not the perfect choices? How about a Caesar salad with chicken? Or something sweet from our dessert options to complete your meal? Swing by and put some YUM in your life!
Other choices
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

See our most popular items

Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about

Welcome to the New Classic!

Welcome to the New Classic!
No matter where you're from or what kind of pizza you prefer, you can come to us for an amazing meal. We're a family-friendly pizza restaurant where locals can enjoy the comfort of a hometown favorite, sports teams can celebrate a win after the game, college students can get a quick bite to eat, and tourists can enjoy the best of the Oneonta food scene. You'll leave our restaurant with a full stomach and a big smile on your face - we guarantee it!
Read More

In-Store Specials

In-Store Specials
Every Day Lunch Special: buy any 2 slices, get a free small fountain drink. Available until 2pm. IN-STORE ONLY!

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

While visiting the area, my hubby and I stopped into Sal’s Pizza about 7 times out of a two week period of time…it is that amazing!!! Seriously, some of the best pizza you will ever try. The white pizza by the slice with tomato, ricotta, and spinach is my favorite, but we absolutely loved every variety we tried….and we tried a lot!!! The crust is just right…chewy with a crunch on the bottom. They warm up the slices in the oven before serving. All of the staff are welcoming and lovely. We would rate over 5 stars if we could. Thank you Sal's for making our vacation!!!!

Be S.

Be S.

My family was in town from Chicago (Southside, so you know we have good pizza) for baseball and we stumbled across this place and they did not disappoint. The pizza was pretty damn good, the crust was amazing and the ingredients were fresh. We tried the supreme, ricotta/spinach/tomato and pepperoni and sausage. I’d give them 10 stars if I could because they were able to accommodate my daughter who has sever dairy allergies with her own pizza with vegan cheese, which I ended up also eating cause the vegan cheese was delicious too.

Vanessa K.

Vanessa K.

Best pizza place in Oneonta, NY! You must try the upside-down, tomato pie, slice. Great quality pizza. Friendly and hard-working staff!

Sydney N.

Sydney N.

Featuring

Family-Owned

Pizza by the Slice

Easy Parking

Vegetarian Options

Sal's New Classic Pizzeria Rewards

Sal's New Classic Pizzeria Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

We're also available on Slice!

We're also available on Slice!
We’re available on Slice if you prefer to order there! 🎉 Please note that loyalty points are only issued from our website! 🍽️
Order on Slice

Frequently asked questions

Our location